Home > Savings insights > 5 misconceptions about insuring a learner driver

5 misconceptions about insuring a learner driver

If you’re a parent wondering what the best way is to help your young driver get extra driving practice - you may be wondering if, and how, you can get them covered!

Breaking down the myths

There are a few common misconceptions when it comes to insuring a learner driver - we’re here to set the record straight and help you find the best way!

1. You can’t insure a provisional licence holder on their own car

Not true! At Marmalade, we get a number of calls from parents who think they have to wait until the learner has passed their test to start their own policy. If they’re lucky enough to have their own car - they can have their own insurance on that car anytime from when they get their provisional licence. Marmalade’s black box insurance covers them seamlessly from learner through to full licence. The great news is there is no increase in price when they pass and they will start earning their own No Claims Discount!

2. Buying a separate policy for the learner will invalidate my insurance

Incorrect! You may think this sounds like dual insurance, which is where the same risk (the car in this case) is insured by more than one policy. The clever thing about Learner Driver Insurance is that we’re actually insuring the learner driver when they are behind the wheel of the car - rather insuring the car at all times. The cover is comprehensive, and even better - there is no risk to your no claims bonus, as it’s completely separate to the main insurance. This also means, you can insure more than one learner at a time on a parent’s car - if you’re ‘lucky’ enough to be helping more than one child through their driving test at the same time!

3. It’s more expensive to insure a learner than a full licence holder

You would be forgiven for thinking that insurance for learner drivers would be ridiculously expensive as they have next to no experience on the roads, and that insurance for a full licence holder may be cheaper. The truth is that the learner driver is likely to be driving around quieter roads and is likely to be driving slowly and carefully.

In addition to this they are always supervised by an experienced driver. Plus, as they’re displaying L plates, other drivers are very aware of their inexperienced status so most sensible drivers are likely to give them space. This actually means the risk of a claim isn’t that high.

Compare this to a newly qualified driver that is driving solo for the first time on a new road, without an experienced driver on hand for help and advice - the risk here is higher, hence insurance for newly qualified drivers is often the most expensive time to buy insurance. Fear not though, black box insurance helps to keep the costs down - and crucially, can reduce the risk of accident for new drivers by around 73%*!

4. Learner drivers can’t earn No Claims Bonus

If you’re thinking your learner won’t be able to start earning their own No Claims Bonus until they have their full licence, you’re wrong. Whilst it may take a learner driver 6 months’ on average to pass their test (not enough time to earn a year of No Claims), choosing an annual policy that continues to cover them after they pass will help them earn that money saving NCD much sooner. The great news is that Marmalade offers learner to full licence insurance on a parent’s car or on their own car - and the price won’t go up when they pass!

5. A car that’s old and cheap to replace makes a good first car

This could be a costly mistake. We understand the logic behind this in that you may be thinking that a cheap car that is cheap to replace will be cheaper to insure if it’s damaged or written off - however, it’s not just the cost of replacing the car that is considered when insurers quote for the risk.

They are also looking at the likelihood of that car being in an accident that causes damage to a third party or property. The fact is that older cars have less safety features and may be heavier - so may in fact lead to more expensive third-party claims. Higher risk means higher premiums. As newer cars have more safety features, they are actually lower risk so may be cheaper to insure. I know we’re only talking about insurance in this article, but an “old banger” may also be costly in terms of repair and running costs. We advise any parent to get young driver insurance quotes on any car they are considering before they commit to buying to check it is affordable.

So there you have it, 5 myths about insurance de-bunked! A lot has changed since most of us parents learned to drive, with many more flexible options for young drivers to get behind the wheel for extra practice to prepare them for life on the road.

Marmalade are proud to work with OneFamily to provide insurance options for young drivers at every stage of driving as well as tips and advice on learning to drive and how to become a safer driver. Visit to discover more.

Close up portrait of pleasant looking female with glad positive expression, being satisfied with unforgettable journey by car, sits on driver`s seat, enjoys music. People, driving, transport concept

Ready to get behind the wheel?

Have you heard of Marmalade?

Marmalade is a car insurance provider designed especially for young drivers, whether they've passed their test or not. It offers pay as you go insurance, which you can use on your parents' car, and black box insurance for insuring your own car.

Visit Marmalade's website for a quote

*Based on Marmalade Black Box Insurance policies incepted 8th October 2018 – 30th November 2019. 1 in 19 Marmalade drivers have an accident during their policy term, compared with 1 in 5 young drivers who have an accident in the first 6 months after passing their test, according to National Statistics. Correct as of 9.01.2019.

Alex Johnson, Brand Manager, Marmalade

Alex Johnson is Brand Manager at Marmalade, an insurance provider for learners and young drivers

You may also be interested in:

The cost of learning to drive

Learning to drive may be a near-universal milestone, but it doesn’t come cheap. Here we break down the cost of learning to drive, as well as money saving tips...

Tips to help your teen start their driving journey

Hands up if it seems like yesterday that you were waving your little one off to school and helping them to ride a bike?

5 reasons you should get insured on your parent’s car

You just passed your driving test but don’t yet have your own car, so how can you start driving? Find out the benefits of getting insured on your parents' car!

Pocket money or part-time work: what's best for my teen?

Experience is key to helping your teen learn how to manage money. But should you give them pocket money or should they get a part-time job?